Although some regard it as america’s first “federal” constitution, in fact, it gave so few powers to the central american government that it was more like a treaty among the thirteen independent states than a constitution for a new nation. Essay: how democratic is the american constitution introduction in a series of works, political scientists robert dahl (b 1915) and historian howard zinn (1922-2010) developed a fierce critique on the undemocratic nature of the early us legislators. Communication bulletin of the american academy winter 2007 31 our undemocratic constitution: where the us constitution goes wrong (and how we the people can correct it) sanford levinson response by barney frank and robert c post this presentation was given on october 30, 2006, at the house of the academy. In this book dahl explains some of the democratic and undemocratic aspects of the american constitution he also explains what should be changed to improve it in chapter 2, dahl begins explaining about the framers of the constitution who had the task of basically creating a new government that combated all of the problems of the new united states of america.
The us constitution: undemocratic us electoral system (essay sample) instructions: the task was about the us constitution system by discussing different bodies such as the senate by stating their nature under the constitution and their powers. How democratic is the american constitution essay nathaniel sellis american & wyo government dudley november 12, 2011 how democratic is the american constitution summary robert dahl explains in the beginning of the book that he is not proposing changes in the american constitution, but suggests changes in the way we think about our constitution.
The united state constitution was written to establish a democratic style of government for american citizens analyze the legislative branch then the executive branch and finally the judicial branch and their descriptions in the constitution to uncover their undemocratic ways how democratic is the us constitution anti essays.
The constitutional convention drafted the constitution in 1787 essays - after the failure of the articles of confederation exemplified by shay’s rebellion in 1787, the young united states needed a new government with improved policies. The debate among the delegates over the nature of the american presidency was more high- toned and more protracted than that over representation in the congress at one extreme, nationalists like james wilson and gouverneur morris argued forcefully for a strong, independent executive capable of giving “energy, dispatch, and responsibility” to the government.
The first step of the constitution was undemocratic no popular vote was taken either directly or indirectly on the proposition to approve a convention (beard 14) the group of men who wanted the convention was skillful in getting it approved in that their proposal of it was a surprise. The popularly held myth that the american constitution is the beacon of global democracy blatantly disregards democratic norms in several instances robert dahl, a sterling professor emeritus of yale university and former president of the american political science association, examines the ways in which the constitution does not practice equality of representation.
The initial constitution contained seven shortcomings that limited its democratic nature: (1) it allowed slavery (2) it failed to guarantee the right of suffrage (3) it created the electoral college and insulated the president from a popular majority. The constitution created a republic a republic is a form of democracy, but slightly different from a pure democracy to increase its appeal to smaller states the constitution was created to protect the minority from the majority this is the reason for the electoral college system.
The popularly held myth that the american constitution is the beacon of global democracy blatantly disregards democratic norms in several instances robert despite the highly undemocratic nature of the senate, an amendment that significantly alters this constitutional body is unlikely to be enacted (160-164. Some other items that are viewed as proof that the constitution is undemocratic are: the ratification process, the senate and the way each state is represented, and in article i, section 2, a slave counts as 3/5 of a person these are just some of the ideas that provide evidence as to why the constitution is thought to be undemocratic.
The undemocratic nature of the american constitution essay sample robert a dahl in his book “how democratic is the american constitution” points out several ‘undemocratic elements in the framers’ constitution’ and uses them as justification to question the democratic intents of the fathers of the constitution. The united state constitution was written to establish a democratic style of government for american citizens a democracy can be defined as the type of government where as all citizens of a country actively participate in government, where citizens uphold the right to decide on laws that affect their lives and where the government acts to.